By Razma
12th February 2009.
14:35
I am glad to see something new in WM interfaces, however, this just does not make it for me, at least with this version.
My main complaint about PointUI 2 is that the screen usage is rather poor. First It’s obviously a quick port of a vga layout. Don’t be fooled by the screenshot above by xperiancers which shows a somewhat neatly agenced screen in vga: on your wvga screen, it renders absolutely the same, with a lot of wasted space at the bottom instead of enlarging the applet space and giving more information.
The applet selector (middle “ribbon”) takes a lot of space too: huge layout for such tiny icons you can’t even clic on. You have to credit touchflo3d here for merging the concept of applet selector and notification icons.
Navigation using traditionnal keypad is not usable at this moment as it is plagued with incoherent schemes. There are hundred examples like “if I hit right key from one task item, it does not do the same as hitting the same key on the task item just below”.
So, it has to be a touch interface, right? Not really: too much small icons lie everywhere. Just try to open pocket outlook with this small “+” icon for example.
Important features are missing:
phonecalls/message notifications at a glance
quick access to your agenda
quick access to browser
Then I understand this is beta, but there is a real whole lot of bugs, ranging from display glitches (email and task applets strangely refresh when selected) to showstopers (My applications panel loose application paths when restarting the panel forcing me to reconfigure all application shortcuts each time I launch the panel).
Finally, but this is more a matter of personnal taste, I’m not really fond of black and white interfaces.
Seems to mee there is still a long road for PointUI to win my heart.
1
0



Sort by